Season Two Episode Three | All Things Cheap Old Houses with Elizabeth and Ethan Finkelstein
What does an old house mean to us?
For this episode of Things I Learned from My Mother from Arcadian Revival, I sit down with Elizabeth and Ethan Finkelstein, the founders of Cheap Old Houses, to talk about much more than old houses.
Over the past decade, Cheap Old Houses has introduced millions of people to forgotten houses across America: places with peeling wallpaper, original woodwork, old kitchens, beautiful proportions, histories, and stories that might otherwise disappear. What began as an Instagram account has grown into a cultural phenomenon and a much larger conversation about how we think about home, history, architecture, preservation, and the places we choose to invest in. Elizabeth and Ethan have created something remarkable by helping people see possibility where others might see decay. In this conversation, we talk about why old houses continue to capture our imagination, and what it is about their imperfections, materials, craftsmanship, patina, and accumulated history that can feel so meaningful in an increasingly fast and digitally mediated world.
We talk about the sensory experience of an old house: the perfect creak of a stair, secret nooks that carry magic. These details connect us to something tangible at a moment when so much of our lives are becoming increasingly virtual, automated, and shaped by artificial intelligence.
We also talk about the enormous cultural footprint Elizabeth and Ethan have created through Cheap Old Houses and how their work has expanded beyond individual properties. Saving an old house in a small Midwestern town, a rural community, or another part of the country is not only about preserving a building. It can mean preserving a piece of local history, supporting a community, maintaining a sense of place, and giving a future generation the opportunity to encounter something that might otherwise have been lost.
Stewardship is a central theme of our conversation. We talk about what it means to invest in an existing home rather than simply replacing it, and the environmental, financial, emotional, and cultural dimensions of restoring an old house. We explore sustainability not simply as a question of energy efficiency or environmental impact, but as a broader question of whether the things we build, repair, care for, and pass along can endure. There is a deeply human side to the work. Elizabeth and Ethan share stories from their own childhoods and experiences with houses and places, and we talk about why certain buildings stay with us. We discuss the emotional connection people develop with homes, the responsibility that comes with taking on an old property, and the idea that a house can belong to a much longer story than the people living in it at any given moment.
Old houses often carry architecture, memory, culture, environmental stewardship, history, and human experience at once and is perhaps part of the reason Cheap Old Houses has resonated so deeply with such a large audience. In a culture increasingly oriented toward speed, novelty, convenience, and digital connection, there is something powerful about being reminded that some things are worth slowing down for, repairing, learning from, and carrying forward. This is a conversation about old houses, but ultimately, it is about what we choose to preserve, what we value enough to care for, and what we hope will still be here when we are gone.
Elizabeth and Ethan Finkelstein are the creators of Cheap Old Houses, the widely followed platform dedicated to sharing affordable historic homes and inspiring people to preserve and restore them. Through their work, they have helped bring historic architecture and preservation into the mainstream and created a community of people interested in old houses, restoration, architecture, and the stories embedded in the places we inhabit.
Things I Learned from My Mother from Arcadian Revival is a podcast exploring home through stories, generational wisdom, and our relationship with the natural world. In this episode we confirm that home is never just a house, it is part of a much longer story.